Insurance Claim vs. Commission Claim: Why Filing With the Virginia Workers’ Comp Commission Matters

After a work injury, you report it to your employer, the insurance company opens a file, and maybe your medical bills start getting paid and checks start arriving. It's easy to assume your claim is "filed" and your rights are protected.

They may not be. Filing a claim with your employer's workers' compensation insurance company is not the same as filing a formal claim with the Virginia Workers' Compensation Commission (VWC). Notifying your employer and working with its insurer can get your medical care and lost wages started, but only filing a formal Claim Form with the Commission legally protects your rights under Virginia law.

Understanding the Differences

Filing With the Insurance Company Filing With the Virginia Workers' Compensation Commission
Purpose To make an initial decision on whether an accident is covered under the Virginia Workers' Compensation Act, and whether medical bills or compensation will be paid To legally preserve your right to benefits and resolve disputes
Role Evaluates, approves or denies claims; pays money and medical benefits Virginia's work injury court. It doesn't pay benefits itself, but it is the only body with the authority to order the insurance company to pay when it doesn't want to
Case ID Uses its own insurance claim number Assigns an official Jurisdiction Claim Number (JCN)
Deadline You must notify your employer within 30 days of the injury You must file a formal Claim Form within 2 years of the accident

Why the Commission Claim Matters: The Award Order

Until the Commission enters an Award Order, the insurance company's payment of your wage loss and medical benefits is purely voluntary. The adjuster can choose to approve benefits or not, and choosing not to is not illegal.

An Award Order is the Commission's formal recognition that your injury is protected under the Workers' Compensation Act. It is what puts the insurance company on the hook for your lifetime medical care related to the injury, and for wage loss benefits while you are fully or partially disabled. Once an award is in place, the insurer can face fines and penalties for failing to provide those benefits.

Why Dealing Only With the Insurance Company Is a Risk

Even if the insurer is paying your medical bills and sending you checks, your rights are not fully secured until the Commission issues an Award Order.

The Two-Year Clock

If you deal only with the insurance company and don't file a Claim Form with the Commission within two years of your accident, the insurance company can legally stop paying you with no warning. Once that deadline passes, unless an exception applies or a workaround can be found, there is a very real risk you'll lose your legal right to make them pay.

Disputes Go to the Commission, Not Civil Court

If the insurer suddenly denies a medical procedure or cuts off your checks, you can't take it to civil court. You must request a hearing before the Virginia Workers' Compensation Commission. Having a claim already on file puts you in a position to do that quickly.

How to File With the Commission

You can file your formal Claim Form with the Virginia Workers' Compensation Commission online through VWC WebFile or by mail. Keep a copy of everything you file, and write down your Jurisdiction Claim Number (JCN) once it's assigned.

To protect yourself, always file a formal Claim Form with the Commission, even if the insurance company seems cooperative.

Talk to a Virginia Workers' Comp Attorney

If you're not sure whether a claim has been filed with the Commission, or the insurer is paying now but you're worried about it later, Thomas & Thomas Law offers a free consultation. Call 540-613-8616 or fill out our Workers' Comp Consultation Form.

Related: Virginia Workers' Comp FAQs · Virginia Workers' Compensation Attorney

author avatar
J Aaron Thomas Licensed Virginia Worker's Compensation Attorney
Virginia Workers Comp Attorney J. Aaron Thomas is both, a licensed Physical Therapist and an attorney licensed with the State of Virginia. he has recovered millions of dollars in combined settlements for his workers' compensation clients since 2013. He has been successful at the hearing level and has overturned numerous unfavorable claimant decisions with the Virginia Worker's Comp Commission.